Plug-related canaliculitis: a rare or underdiagnosed disease?

CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Conjunctivitis, chalazion and blepharitis are routinely managed by optometrists. However, it is especially important to consider the diagnosis of canaliculitis in patients with chronic or recurrent conditions. BACKGROUND: This study aimed to report the clinical features, radiological findings and treatment outcomes in patients with plug-related canaliculitis. METHODS: This retrospective study included patients with canaliculitis secondary to plug insertion between 2007 and 2020. All data regarding epidemiological characteristics, clinical presentation, isolated microorganisms, computed tomography imaging findings, treatment, and outcomes were analysed. RESULTS: A total of 20 plug-related canaliculitis from 19 patients (18.3%) among all 109 cases of canaliculitis were identified. All patients with plug-related canaliculitis were females with a past history of lacrimal plug insertion for dry eye (mean age: 58.2 years). Most patients were initially treated as conjunctivitis with the mean time lapse to a diagnosis of 5.2 months. The average time from plug insertion to onset of symptoms was 5.1 years. Eighteen patients underwent canaliculotomy, and one patient received lacrimal irrigation. Plugs were identified in 18 cases, with SmartPlug in 13 cases (72%), followed by EaglePlugTM (two cases), Herrick Lacrimal Plug (two cases), and migrated FCI Painless Plug (1 case). Cultures of discharge, concretions, and/or infected plugs mostly revealed Pseudomonas aeruginosa (42%). Orbital computed tomography in four cases with SmartPlug revealed central radiolucency with surrounding soft-tissue enhancement. No recurrent canaliculitis was observed throughout a mean follow-up period of 13.7 months. No patient needed re-plugging after canaliculotomy and plug removal, with only one required additional lubricants for recurrent dry eye. CONCLUSION: Plug-related canaliculitis is often underdiagnosed due to late onset and similar symptoms to common ocular diseases. Awareness of plug insertion history as well as meticulous removal of the plug, concretion and/or granulation tissue is important for early diagnosis and to ensure a good outcome.

Metagenomic Shotgun Sequencing Analysis of Canalicular Concretions in Lacrimal Canaliculitis Cases.

Lacrimal canaliculitis is a rare infection of the lacrimal canaliculi with canalicular concretions formed by aggregation of organisms. Metagenomic shotgun sequencing analysis using next-generation sequencing has been used to detect pathogens directly from clinical samples. Using this technology, we report cases of successful pathogen detection of canalicular concretions in lacrimal canaliculitis cases. We investigated patients with primary lacrimal canaliculitis examined in the eye clinics of four hospitals from February 2015 to July 2017. Eighteen canalicular concretion specimens collected from 18 eyes of 17 patients were analyzed by shotgun metagenomics sequencing using the MiSeq platform (Illumina). Taxonomic classification was performed using the GenBank NT database. The canalicular concretion diversity was characterized using the Shannon diversity index. This study included 18 eyes (17 patients, 77.1 ± 6.1 years): 82.4% were women with lacrimal canaliculitis; canalicular concretions were obtained from 12 eyes using lacrimal endoscopy and six eyes using canaliculotomy with curettage. Sequencing analysis detected bacteria in all samples (Shannon diversity index, 0.05-1.47). The following genera of anaerobic bacteria (>1% abundance) were identified: Actinomyces spp. in 15 eyes, Propionibacterium spp., Parvimonas spp. in 11 eyes, Prevotella spp. in 9 eyes, Fusobacterium spp. in 6 eyes, Selenomonas spp. in 5 eyes, Aggregatibacter spp. in 3 eyes, facultative and aerobic bacteria such as Streptococcus spp. in 13 eyes, Campylobacter spp. in 6 eyes, and Haemophilus spp. in 3 eyes. The most common combinations were Actinomyces spp. and Streptococcus spp. and Parvinomonas spp. and Streptococcus spp., found in 10 cases. Pathogens were identified successfully using metagenomic shotgun sequencing analysis in patients with canalicular concretions. Canalicular concretions are polymicrobial with anaerobic and facultative, aerobic bacteria.

Update on Idiopathic Canalicular Inflammatory Disease (ICID): Outcomes With Addition of Topical Cyclosporine and the Modified Treatment Protocol.

PURPOSE: The objective of this study is to present clinical outcomes with addition of topical cyclosporine while managing cases of "idiopathic canalicular inflammatory disease" and to propose a modified treatment protocol. METHODS: Prospective case series of 88 canaliculi of 44 eyes of 22 patients diagnosed as "idiopathic canalicular inflammatory disease" at a tertiary care Dacryology service over a period of 2 years. All the patients were diagnosed based on the published major and minor criteria and each of the canaliculus was clinically staged. All patients were treated initially with a combination of topical cyclosporine (0.05%) and rapidly tapering topical steroids followed by punctal dilatation and placement of mini-monoka stents after control of inflammation. Monoka stents were extubated at 6 weeks and the cyclosporine was continued for at least up to 3 months beyond the extubation of stents. Patient demographics, investigations, response to cyclosporine, management modalities, recurrence of inflammation, anatomical and functional outcomes were analyzed. RESULTS: Eighty-eight canaliculi were diagnosed to have idiopathic canalicular inflammatory disease during the study period. There was a female preponderance (77%, 17/22) and the mean age at presentation was 51 years. All patients presented with bilateral epiphora (mean duration 4.5 months) without any discharge. Staging revealed 18, 27, 24, and 19 canaliculi were involved with stages 1-4, respectively. The mean duration of cyclosporine use was 5.7 months. All patients except 3 (19/22) underwent monoka dilatation. Complete anatomical and functional resolution were noted in 62% (55/88), of which 12 puncta and canaliculi, all stage 1 (13.6%, 12/88) showed complete resolution with cyclosporine alone. Relentless disease progression to stage 5 was noted in 30% (26/88) of the puncta and canaliculi. All the younger patients (<30 years, 13.6%, 3/22) demonstrated poor outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: The addition of topical cyclosporine is beneficial in controlling inflammation and disease downstaging in patients with idiopathic canalicular inflammatory disease. The current modified treatment protocol salvages majority of the canaliculi.

Canaliculitis / Canaliculitis

RESUMEN La canaliculitis es una entidad rara, con frecuencia mal diagnosticada por su similitud con otras enfermedades. Se reporta una paciente femenina, de 56 años de edad, remitida a la Consulta de Oculoplastia del Instituto Cubano de Oftalmología "Ramón Pando Ferrer", por secreciones purulentas y epífora del ojo izquierdo. Al examen se observó hiperemia conjuntival, secreción purulenta, punto lagrimal inferior hiperémico, dilatado, y se constató salida de concreciones por este al comprimir el canalículo. Se confirmó el diagnóstico de canaliculitis aguda supurada con concreciones. Se indicó tratamiento quirúrgico, que consistió en la canaliculotomía con remoción de las concreciones. Un examen clínico detallado, con adecuado conocimiento de la vía lagrimal excretora, permitió el diagnóstico certero, con un tratamiento quirúrgico eficaz y una evolución satisfactoria(AU)

ABSTRACT Canaliculitis is an uncommon infectious disease. It is often misdiagnosed due to its overlapping presentation to other common entities. A 56-year-old female patient is reported. She was referred to Ramón Pando Ferrer Cuban Ophthalmologic Institute, Ocular Plastic Surgery consultation, suffering from punctal swelling, discharge, and epiphora. At ocular examination was described conjunctival hyperemia, pouting punctum and mucopurulent discharge. Punctal regurgitation of concretions appears under syringing. It was confirmed acute canaliculitis with concretions in the left eye. A canaliculotomy was performed, and the concretions were removed. Routine clinical examinations helped to get a right diagnosis of canaliculitis and the surgical result was satisfactory(AU)

Infectious keratitis secondary to canaliculitis with concretions: A case report.

RATIONALE: Canaliculitis is a frequently overlooked and misdiagnosed disease. Concurrent corneal ulceration with canaliculitis is uncommon. We report such a case. PATIENT CONCERNS: An 87-year-old woman complained of swelling and pain of the right eye after acute angle closure glaucoma attack. Slit-lamp examination was compatible with the features of infectious keratitis, and the cultures from corneal scrapings grew Streptococcus anginosus later. Hourly topical vancomycin (25 mg/ml) was instilled, then the corneal ulceration improved initially but became stationary after 1-week treatment. DIAGNOSIS: Discharge from the upper punctum was noted subsequently and canalicular concretions were found through curettage. The cultures from canalicular discharge and concretions also revealed the presence of S. anginosus. Thus, infectious keratitis secondary to canaliculitis was diagnosed. INTERVENTIONS: Canaliculotomy was performed to remove the large concretion and vancomycin was injected locally. OUTCOMES: The corneal ulceration resolved after canaliculitis was appropriately treated. LESSONS: Canaliculitis could be a reservoir for organisms that may make compromised corneas liable to infections. Only the appropriate diagnosis and aggressive treatment of canaliculitis leads to the eradication of associated corneal infections.

Acute Sterile Canaliculitis: A Case Report and Review of the Literature.

A 53-year-old male developed secondary canaliculitis after undergoing nasolacrimal intubation with a silicone stent. Negative cultures, symptoms refractory to antibiotics, and rapid resolution after stent removal suggest an immune reaction as the mechanism of canaliculitis. This case raises awareness of noninfectious hypersensitivity or hypersensitivity-like reactions as a potential acute or subacute complication of nasolacrimal stenting.

Idiopathic Canalicular Inflammatory Disease: New Disease Description of Clinical Patterns, Investigations, Management, and Outcomes.

PURPOSE: The objective of this perspective is to present a separate disease description of "idiopathic canalicular inflammatory disease" and outline the diagnostic criteria and early experiences with its investigations and management. METHODS: Retrospective case series of 44 canaliculi of 22 eyes of 11 patients presenting at a tertiary care Dacryology service over a period of 2 years with typical clinical patterns of inflammatory canaliculitis and its outcomes were studied. All the patients underwent microbiological work-up with culture and sensitivity, dacryoendoscopy imaging, serial Fourier domain ocular coherence tomography, and collagen vascular profiles. Stages in the evolution of the disease were studied. All patients were treated initially with topical steroids followed by punctal dilatation and placement of mini-monoka stents. Five patients in addition had a small biopsy from the inflamed portion of the vertical canaliculus. Stents were extubated at 6 weeks. RESULTS: Forty-four canaliculi were diagnosed to have idiopathic canalicular inflammatory disease during the study period. There was a female preponderance (81.8%, 9/11) and the mean age at presentation was 57 years. All patients presented with unilateral epiphora without any discharge, pain, or swelling. Collagen vascular profiles and screening for autoimmune diseases were negative. Clinical picture ranged from stages 1 to 5, consisting of edema, progressive centripetal vascularization, pouting of vascularized mucosa, membrane formation, and progressive scarring. The presentation begins in 1 eye and usually involves the other eye at a mean of 6 months. Ocular coherence tomography and dacryoendoscopy were of adjunctive value in the diagnosis. Histopathological examination was suggestive of a chronic inflammation. All patients had relentless progression to end-stage disease, although delayed significantly by steroids and monoka intubation. CONCLUSION: Idiopathic canalicular inflammatory disease has a distinct and typical clinical behavior and the current study proposed diagnostic features and disease staging. The use of topical and systemic immunosuppressive agents needs to be explored to formulate effective protocols for its management.

Incision-sparing management of canaliculitis: an efficacious alternative to surgical management.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to describe the outcomes of conservative (punctal dilation, manual expression, microcurettage, and canalicular irrigation with antibiotics) and surgical (punctoplasty) modalities for the management of canaliculitis in an Asian population. METHODS: The medical records of 11 consecutive patients (12 eyes) presenting with canaliculitis to one surgeon from August 2010 to January 2014 were reviewed. The clinical presentation, findings, management, microbiology, and treatment outcomes were studied. RESULTS: The mean age was 70.6 years (57-91 years), 8 (72.7%) patients were females, and all 11(100%) were Chinese. The majority had unilateral canaliculitis-8 (66.7%) right eye only and 4 (33.3%) left eye only (1 patient had consecutive right canaliculitis followed by left canaliculitis)-involving the lower canaliculi (75%). Ten (83.3%) eyes had primary canaliculitis, and 2 (16.7%) eyes had secondary canaliculitis from punctal plug insertion. Common presenting symptoms included eye discharge (75%) and eyelid swelling/redness (50%). Common clinical signs included mucopurulent punctal regurgitation (75%) and pouting punctum (58.3%). Facultative anaerobes (56.3%) formed the majority of organisms, and the most common bacteria isolated were Streptococcus spp. (18.8%). Mean duration to definitive treatment was 35 days (0-126 days). Ten (83.3%) eyes were successfully treated with incision-sparing modalities, and 2 (16.7%) eyes were treated surgically. No recurrences were observed at 3, 6, and 12 months, and only 1 (10.0%) of the 10 conservatively managed eyes had a recurrence of canaliculitis after 3.8 years. CONCLUSIONS: Surgical modalities remain effective for the treatment of canaliculitis. However, they are not without disadvantages, such as scarring, discomfort, infection, and recurrence of punctal stenosis. In our experience, incision-sparing modalities are effective in the treatment of canaliculitis and have low recurrence rates.

Clinical features, microbiological profiles and treatment outcome of lacrimal plug-related canaliculitis compared with those of primary canaliculitis.

AIMS: To compare the clinical features and treatment outcome between lacrimal plug-related canaliculitis and primary canaliculitis. METHODS: Patients with plug-related canaliculitis and primary canaliculitis between 2007 and 2014 in a medical centre were collected. Charts were reviewed for clinical features, microbiological profiles, time lapse between plug insertion and symptom onset, type of plug and outcomes. RESULTS: Of 76 eligible cases collected, 13 were plug-related canaliculitis and 63 were primary canaliculitis. The most common presenting symptom was discharge in both groups (85% and 79%, respectively). The average time interval from plug insertion to symptoms onset was 5.5 years. Most canaliculitis developed in women, especially for plug-related canaliculitis, when compared with primary canaliculitis (100% vs 65.1%; p=0.015). The most common isolated microorganism was Pseudomonas aeruginosa in plug-related canaliculitis (46%) and Streptococcus in primary canaliculitis (28%), respectively. Isolation of Pseudomonas was significantly higher in plug-related canaliculitis than in primary canaliculitis (46% vs 12%; p=0.029). Most plug-related canaliculitis resolved after removal of plugs by canaliculotomy (12 cases, 93%). Most identified plug was SmartPlug (seven cases), followed by EaglePlug (two cases) and Herrick Lacrimal Plug (two cases). There was no recurrence in patients with plug-related canaliculitis, however, recurrence developed in seven patients (11%) with primary canaliculitis. CONCLUSIONS: In comparison with primary canaliculitis, plug-related canaliculitis appear to be more prevalent in women and show a different microbiological profile. Retrieval of infected plug by canaliculotomy and adequate antibiotics can achieve a good outcome. Long-term follow-up is required because canaliculitis may develop several years after plug insertion.

Clinical characteristics, treatment patterns, and outcomes of primary canaliculitis among patients in Beijing, China.

BACKGROUND: Canaliculitis may cause punctal or canalicular swelling, discharge, erythema, and sometimes concretions. This study examined the clinical characteristics, treatment patterns, and outcomes of primary canaliculitis from patients at a top-rated hospital in Beijing, China. METHODS: Medical records of 16 patients (retrospective case series) were studied. RESULTS: This study included four males and twelve females with a median age of 72.5 years. The mean and the median follow-up time were 10.4 months and 6 months, respectively. The mostly observed clinical symptoms were epiphora with discharge (94%), while the mostly observed signs included pouting punctum (75%) and punctal regurgitation of concretions under syringing (75%). Only the symptoms of one patient among those with conservative therapy completely resolved within two-year follow-up. Curettage therapy was found to partly resolve the clinical symptoms and signs within the follow-up of four weeks. Fifteen patients finally received curettage with punctoplasty, and symptoms completely resolved in fourteen patients after one surgery. CONCLUSIONS: Syringing with pressing of lacrimal sac area may help better diagnosis of canaliculitis. Additionally, curettage with punctoplasty is recommended for thorough removal of concretions and complete resolution of canaliculitis.